Why New York Could Owe Peanut The Squirrel’s Owners $10 Million After State Seized And Euthanized Pet

The State of New York may be facing a $10 million payout after the seizure and euthanasia of Peanut the Squirrel, a well-known social media sensation.

Peanut became famous over seven years ago, building an audience of more than 900,000 followers on Instagram at the height of his popularity.

His rise to internet fame began when his owners, married couple Mark Longo and Daniela Bittner, started dressing him in costumes and teaching him playful tricks that quickly captured hearts online.

But in October 2024, Peanut and his companion, “Fred the Raccoon,” were seized by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) and euthanized.

Longo announced the heartbreaking news on Instagram, writing: “Well internet, you WON.”

“You took one of the most amazing animals away from me because of your selfishness. To the group of people who called DEC, there’s a special place in hell for you.”

Peanut was euthanized by the state in October Instagram/@peanut_the_squirrel12
“Today at 10am Wednesday, Oct 30, 2024… The NY State DEC showed up to my house and took Peanut. He was TAKEN to the EUTHANIZED. I’m in shock, disbelief, and disgusted to the people who did this to PNUT.”

“For the last 7 years, Peanut has been my best friend. He’s been the center of my world and many of yours for so long, I don’t know how to process this, emotionally.”

At the time, the county’s health department and the DEC said they had received reports of “potentially unsafe housing of wildlife that could carry rabies and the illegal keeping of wildlife as pets,” according to USA Today.

Now, the grieving couple is demanding $10 million in compensation, arguing that the state’s actions caused them emotional devastation, financial loss, and the destruction of their livelihood. The legal complaint, filed on August 7, and reported by the New York Post, also describes the seizure as the “execution” of their pets.

While it is illegal to keep wild animals such as squirrels and raccoons as pets in New York, DEC officials claimed that Peanut bit an agent through thick leather gloves during the alleged five-hour raid, prompting rabies testing for both animals.

The state later confirmed both rabies tests were negative. However, the lawsuit says the DEC never apologized or returned the bodies.

Fred was also killed after the raid Instagram/@peanut_the_squirrel12
The court filing alleges that the killings were not motivated by rabies concerns but were instead a “senseless act of violence” and an “obscene demonstration of government abuse.” It names the state, the DEC, and the Department of Health as defendants.

Longo also claims the raid was a premeditated “target” and “assassination,” pointing out that squirrels “do not transmit rabies.”

He alleges that nine officers stormed his home, ransacking it for hours, and insists that Peanut and Fred were not merely euthanized but “executed.”

In addition, Longo and Bittner filed another lawsuit on June 27 in Chemung County Supreme Court. This separate case targets the county, the City of Elmira, and 36 individuals from multiple levels of local and state government, seeking unspecified damages through a jury trial.

“Filing these lawsuits will allow us to create a movement,” Longo told USA Today“This was a heinous act by an overpowering government who overreached.”

“As an animal lover, you love your animal, and you do whatever it takes to protect them,” he continued.

“They destroyed my family. I cry almost every day knowing that that portion of my life and that chapter is closed.”

Nora Constance Marino, the attorney for Longo and Bittner, added: “We hope to obtain justice, not just for my clients and the violation of their rights, but for Peanut and Fred, and all animals. We hope that Peanut’s and Fred’s deaths will not have been in vain.”

The squirrel had international social media fame Instagram/@peanut_the_squirrel12
The couple also says they have endured severe emotional distress and financial setbacks since losing Peanut and Fred.

Peanut’s fame extended well beyond Instagram, with appearances in monetized social media content, on OnlyFans, and in various cameo roles, according to court filings.